Want the latest Discover Card Deals?

Just enter your email address below and we'll send you secret Discover Card deals every month.
Email Address:

My first question is Prepaid Discover Card/Visa card, any good? Looking forward for any answer. Second question.. So I have read a lot on here - some people say absolutely stay off the phone and other say you should use the phone if you feel comfortable..

FYI - I am a head hunter by trade so I have a lot of experience cold calling people - even top executives in major companies. I know how to control a conversation, not get upset and I don't answer stupid "have you stopped stealing from your creditors yet?" question..

This is my intro thread where I explain that I need to get several collection items deleted or showing "paid" to get a particular job..

Http://creditboards....howtopic=422062.

Now - so far:.

1. I paid RJM and it took just over 1 week for their TL to show "Paid".

2. I paid another agency that said they would report on Jan 1st and delete the TL (due to the small amount) - they sent me a letter telling me they were doing this..

3. A utility sent my account to a CA 2 years ago. The balance was long paid, but the CA showed it due..

Last Friday I made some phone calls:.

1. I called the CA mentioned it item #3 above - the guy was really cool and said he would check it out and manually correct it as soon as he confirmed the status. Saturday morning it was marked "paid".

2. This is the biggie:.

I have a TL from a CA claiming I owe over $1000 for a student load from an Online University. I attended for 2 months in 2001 and then lost my job - I went into default right away and made a few payments here and there, but the account is very old and DOLD is probably 8 years..

So I called the CA and said "told them I have not had any student debt in 8+ years and that if the account was mine, it was way beyond SOL and is time barred, etc..

"lets start by updating your information".

I did not call to give you information to help you collect a time barred debt.

"when did you last attend this school?".

I never said I attended it - I just said I have not had any student debt in 8 years and this is a time barred debt, you are violating my rights and you are breaking the law..

[this is where it got crazy].

"I am sorry, I don't understand... how can we help you today?".

Delete the trade line..

"I can't do that but I can take a Discover credit card or online check...".

Do you know what a SOL is?.

"I am not sure what you mean by that - this IS YOUR LOAN, if you did not call to pay, why did you call?".

Is there a supervisor available? someone who understands spoken English?.

"sure".

[that was the short version, he actually went through contortions for a good 5-7 minutes to avoid acknowledging what I was saying].

The super comes on and mirandizes me..

We pretty much repeat the first conversation - again with entering a total comprehension vacuum whenever SOL or time barred comes up..

Then I ask - when was the account opened?.

"this account was opened 3 years ago and you need to pay it!".

When was the debt incurred?.

"sir, this came into our office 3 years ago and you need to pay it!".

Around we go a couple more times..

I told her she was breaking Texas law.

She said "is this a refusal to pay?".

I said "there is nothing to pay!".

Then she hung up..

A day later, they hard pulled my credit (TU)..

Today I am sending them a TFC based DV letter CMRRR..

Now I am interested to hear about the downside of calling a CA - personally, I found it extremely interesting to get a peek into their cognitive dissonance bubble where any easily verifiable fact is transmuted into white noise before entering their ears..

They are clearly re-aging the debt as the drop off date is about 3 years from now and they seemed to be trying to get me to claim the debt or indirectly admit that it was mine - which I did not do and in Texas, you have to promise in writing to re-age a debt properly. The hard pull was not really a surprise, I poked them and they growled. They seem pretty stupid..

What's the worst thing that could happen..

asked Mar 04 at 05:16

Keaton's gravatar image

Keaton
56


I'm stumped. I'm not so sure what is the right answer to your question. I'll do some research in Google and get back to you if I find an useful answer. You should email the people at Discover Card as they probably can help you..

answered Mar 04 at 06:02

Isaiah's gravatar image

Isaiah
2235

The trivial drop in my already basement level FICO score is of no concern to me given the current time horizon for buying another home..

My understanding is that if I were to freeze my CRA reports, that the employer would not be able to re-pull my credit which I need them to do soon..

I am just wondering if there is some other shady tactic I should watch out for..

Thanks for responding George...

answered Mar 04 at 07:26

Kennedi
's gravatar image

Kennedi
2593

You don't like to argue if you're not FROZEN..

answered Mar 04 at 07:53

Jazlyn
's gravatar image

Jazlyn
621

I am sorry, I don't understand what you mean..

I have not frozen anything..

And I do like to argue..

But I am conscious of the fact that not everyone else enjoys the idea of arguing as sport so I don't engage willy-nilly..

Only the bad people..

answered Mar 04 at 08:27

Juliet
's gravatar image

Juliet
4378

EMPLOYMENT IS.

NOT.

A CREDIT PRODUCT.

Soft is not off limits for an application for a "JOB".

You want them to pull again....

THEN DON'T.

FREEZE.

Enjoy the hards.....

answered Mar 04 at 09:03

Heidi
's gravatar image

Heidi
837

Sorry... Freezing your reports prevents random INQ like the one you got (in many cases).

If you had frozen your reports b4 talking at least they couldn't have pulled a hard INQ in response, capiche?.

It is like fighting without armour if you talk to a CA without Freezing reports IMO...

answered Mar 04 at 09:05

Kameron's gravatar image

Kameron
3997

CA Hard inquiries are NOT trivial and further blemish a basement level report for 2 years. VERY MUCH worth avoiding since they can be sticky as all hell..

You can easily freeze and release the report to the employer (or whoever else YOU authorize.)..

answered Mar 04 at 10:09

Wyatt's gravatar image

Wyatt
1547

Hmmm..

Well, at least it was one of the CRAs that seems to be most pliable with diligent B*.

Sounds like I need to get on top of the Freeze and Opt-out asap..

I am not paranoid, but I did have a thing in the back of my mind that since I called them, they might try to lie and claim I promised to pay them in full plus treble damages or something - or say I begged them to re-age the debt even though they let me know the SOL said I didn't have to, but of course, I insisted so what could they do?..

answered Mar 04 at 10:41

Ruby
's gravatar image

Ruby
1667

Did you by chance record that call, or can they deny what happened?..

answered Mar 04 at 11:01

Melanie
's gravatar image

Melanie
3407

If I had any inkling the call would be so entertaining, I would have recorded it, redacted the ID points and posted it..

I keep meaning to swing by Radio Shack and pick up one of those suction cup mics, but I have not done so yet..

So, there is really no basis for accusing them of anything based on the call, I just did not want them to claim something against me based on their retelling of the call. I doubt that would happen, but it crossed my mind..

I am going to do the freeze and opt out like people suggested, as well as get a mic because I think my calm, controlled style is good at bringing out the crazy in those guys..

Honestly, the phone seems like unexplored territory on here - I can understand why - not all areas are single party consent and many people are just flat not comfortable in adversarial conversations, plus when you get it in writing, it's a lot neater but still... I wonder what could be done.....

answered Mar 04 at 11:43

Liam's gravatar image

Liam
619

Time to get to the shack now.....

That phone call...as you remember it...never happened.....

However, what's to stop them from saying that you agreed to pay, etc?.

The phone is a WELL explored territory...which is why it's suggested in most cases to avoid the phone....

And if you INSIST on using the phone...record it...every time...if you're in a two party state and they don't have "your call may be recorded" at the begining of the call, get consent from them...if they won't give consent, hang up and tell them you'll be happy to discuss it with them when they give consent to record.....

As you can see by your own experience...someone who's comfortable on the phone, knows how to direct the conversation, etc....it served YOU no purpose whatsoever.....

answered Mar 04 at 13:18

Brooklyn
's gravatar image

Brooklyn
545

Good advice..

Just to clarify for the readers:.

1. I am in Texas so it is a 1 party recording state - I don't need their permission to record, although it might be a nice pressure tactic to tell them I am recording them..

2. I took copious notes during the call and emailed the notes to 2 email addresses so at least I have something of a paper trail. If they did try to say I agreed to something silly, I have my notes. If things get really crazy, you could ask for their tape during discovery..

2.a I forgot to mention, I was having trouble getting to a collections person from their main number (how much does it suck if you are a CA and people CANNOT call in and reach collections?) - anyway, I broke out into the employee directory and started dialing extensions until I got someone. Most of the time, this bypasses the computer and they are not able to record a call like this (but not always)..

3. Also, in Texas, you cannot re-age or reset the SOL without it in writing so it's not like they could say a whole lot happened...

answered Mar 04 at 14:29

Helen
's gravatar image

Helen
1605

The people you are speaking with are just earning a paycheck, same as you. If you want results with your credit, you will get them by following the steps that are mentioned in every thread on this website and do it by certified mail. If you're calling just to give these guys a hard time, please keep in mind that they're just trying to feed their families, same as you are..

A little respect goes a long way..

answered Mar 04 at 15:37

Kira
's gravatar image

Kira
32

I may have understood incorrectly, but what I think the OP meant by the bad ones were the CA reps that try to play hardball first(.

Edit:.

Not all CA reps)....

Thats how I read it anyway.

This post has been edited by.

Tryn2getup.

: 12 January 2010 - 01:24 AM..

answered Mar 04 at 16:04

Mariah
's gravatar image

Mariah
1599

True, but do the CAs deserve our respect?.

I haven't met or dealt with many that do....

If they want to feed their families...then get a job in a respectable industry....

Like street walking.....

answered Mar 04 at 16:29

Jaime's gravatar image

Jaime
4166

True, but you.

Want.

Them to hang themselves. No need in giving them a heads-up...

answered Mar 04 at 16:48

Kelvin's gravatar image

Kelvin
1808

+1 good point. no need to show your cards... but I get what you mean OP by figuring they'll know you mean business if you do..

Also, great if you can B* off inq, keeping in mind that won't work on EX...

answered Mar 04 at 17:10

Christian's gravatar image

Christian
419

Freezing is a panacea and makes poop smell good...

answered Mar 04 at 17:40

Emerson
's gravatar image

Emerson
1938

They do allegedly/technically have PP.

It's sort of a work around if you will, since in many cases it prevents the miscreants from their dirty deeds (ie. having an INQ party on your cbr) in any case, far from a panacea, it's just another tool in our arsenal..

This post has been edited by.

Savetherobots.

: 12 January 2010 - 10:55 AM..

answered Mar 04 at 17:55

Jaelyn
's gravatar image

Jaelyn
1403

WHY WORRY ABOUT PP WHEN YOU CAN STOP THE.

CA HARDS.

"IF" you are.

SPECIAL.

And.

CA HARDS.

Don't hurt you....

THEN.

DON'T.

FREEZE..

answered Mar 04 at 18:55

Kaleb's gravatar image

Kaleb
3734

Your answer
toggle preview

powered by OSQA